I don't know this book but I found the description interesting. It was in an old RT BOOK REVIEWS issue. In the section Theme Spotlight - Reincarnation there was only this:

a man is blinded on his wedding day - and then is healed by his beloved - because as a sheriff of the Old West, he was prevented from marrying his fiancé by a bullet

Maybe one of these:

Recommended Reads

(Note: The list below was compiled at press time: RT BOOK REVIEWS Issue #201, November 2000)

PLAY IT AGAIN, SAM Victoria Alexander (Leisure)
CATRIONA Jeanette Baker (Pocket)
MAYBE THIS TIME Victoria Barrett (Zebra)
TIME AFTER TIME Marilynn Byerly (Hardshell Word Factory)
FOREVER AND A DAY Victoria Chancellor (Leisure)
COPPER MOON Roxanne Conrad (Onyx)
LOVE POTION #9 Claire Cross (Jove)
ONCE UPON A KISS Claire Cross (Jove)
A KNIGHT IN SHINING ARMOR Jude Deveraux (Pocket)
LEGEND Jude Deveraux (Pocket)
REMEMBRANCE Jude Deveraux (Pocket)
FLAMES OF RAPTURE Lark Eden (Love Spell)
THE STARRY CHILD Lynn Hanna (Onyx)
LAKE OF DREAMS Linda Howard (Pocket)
ANGEL HOURS Jan Hudson (Pinnacle)
DREAM OF ME Jan Hudson (Pinnacle)
REMEMBER MY HEART Janis Reams Hudson (Pinnacle)
A CASE OF NERVES Angie Kay (Love Spell)
MARIANA Susanna Kearsley (Bantam)
THE BECKONING GHOST Catherine Kohman (Love Spell)
DREAMS: PART ONE & TWO Jayne Ann Krentz (Harlequin)
THERE NEVER WAS A TIME Gail Link (Love Spell)
FERNEY James Long (Bantam)
THE DREAM Kat Martin (Kensington)
DREAMCATCHER Dinah McCall (Harper)
THE COVENANT Modean Moon (Harper)
MAIDEN VOYAGE Judith O'Brien (Pocket)
TAKE MY BREATH AWAY Meg O'Brien (St. Martin's)
THE HORSEMAN Kristina O'Donnelly (Hollis Books)
TWICE UPON A TIME Emilie Richards (Avon)
ONCE MORE WITH FEELING Emilie Richards (Avon)
FOREVER AND A DAY Connie Rinehold (Dell)
BORN IN SHAME Nora Roberts (Jove)
ETERNITY Maggie Shayne (Jove)
NOW AND FOREVER Elizabeth Sherwood (Pinnacle)
BRIDE OF THE MIST Christina Skye (Avon)
BRIDGE OF DREAMS Christina Skye (Avon)
BREAK THE NIGHT Anne Stuart (Pinnacle)

Historical

MAGIC Kimberly Cates (Pocket)
ONCE IN EVERY LIFE Krtistin Hannah (Gold Medal)
ENSLAVED Virginia Henley (Island/Dell)
GREEN DARKNESS Anya Seton (Fawcett)

I tried it before but couldn't find it.
I will search it once more.